Our Weekly Specials

Coming Soon!

Please check back for specials, discounts, and off menu items.

Soup of the Day

Our Current Soups:

Greek Lemon Chicken
French Onion

ORDER NOW

Hours

MONDAY - THURSDAY
8:00 AM - 9:00 PM

FRIDAY - SATURDAY
7:00 AM - 9:00 PM

SUNDAY
7:00 AM - 8:00 PM

DESSERT

DESSERTS

Layer Cakes

10.95

Pie A La Mode

11.95

Fruit Pies

9.95

Large Cookies

6.95

Rice Pudding

7.95

Banana Split

15.95

Ripe Banana with 3 Generous Scoops of Ice Cream,
topped with Whipped Cream, Nuts & Cherry

Waffle Sundae

20.95
Belgian Waffle with 3 Generous Scoops of Ice Cream,
topped with Whipped Cream, Nuts & Cherry

BEVERAGES

Milk

4.50

Chocolate Milk

4.95

Strawberry Milk

4.95

Soda

3.95

Flavored Soda

4.25
Vanilla, Chocolate or Cherry

Natural Spring Water

3.00

(served by the Bottle)

Hot Coffee

3.75

Decaf Coffee

3.75

Hot Tea - Reg or Decaf

3.75

(with Honey .50 extra)

Herbal Tea

4.50

Iced Tea or Iced Coffee

4.25

Hot Chocolate

4.50

FOUNTAIN

Ice Cream Soda

All Flavors - 8.95

MILKSHAKE

Vanilla, Chocolate or Strawberry

8.95

Double Thick Milkshake

10.95
Made extra thick with Four Scoops of Ice Cream and
poured straight from its own mixing can (vanilla,
chocolate or strawberry)

Banana Vanilla Milkshake

9.95

Strawberry Banana Milkshake

9.95

EGG CREAM

Vanilla, Chocolate or Strawberry

5.95

Ice Cream

2 Scoops - 8.95

Sundae

10.95

Sundae with Fruit

11.95

SMOOTHIES

Strawberry and Banana Smoothie

10.95

made with Splenda and Crushed Ice

Banana Smoothie

9.95

made with Splenda and Crushed Ice

Brooke Walsh -

I always love going to the Setauket diner, it’s always a positive experience!! (: The waitresses and waiters are extremely friendly, food is always amazing, every time I step foot into the diner.. Gus always greets us with smile and my boyfriend and I enjoy our conversations with him! We love Gus and everyone at the Setauket diner ☺️

James Yeary -

This has become my go-to diner over the last year or so. All of the food is 10/10 and the owner/servers provide such an awesome experience. Would highly recommend!!

Andrew Negron -

What an amazing vibe. I feel like I in a different world here. This might not be the most important thing to everyone, but the over medium egg sandwich is one of a kind. The bacon? Prefect! The roll? Like it came right out of the oven. And an over medium egg is a hard cook to get perfect. But every time I get one it's on the money. Thank you guy.

Rick E. -

Cozy and comfortable local restaurant with great food and a wonderful host. You always feel welcomed here.

DOWNLOAD OUR MENU

Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Full Menu

CALL US

631-941-3826

HOURS

MONDAY - THURSDAY
8:00 AM - 9:00 PM

FRIDAY - SATURDAY
7:00 AM - 9:00 PM

SUNDAY
7:00 AM - 8:00 PM

CONNECT