Our Weekly Specials

Coming Soon!

Please check back for specials, discounts, and off menu items.

Soup of the Day

Our Current Soups:

Greek Lemon Chicken
French Onion

ORDER NOW

Hours

MONDAY - SATURDAY
7:00 AM - 9:00 PM

SUNDAYS
7:00 AM - 8:00 PM

LUNCH

TRIPLE DECKERS

PREPARED WITH LETTUCE AND TOMATO
SERVED WITH COLE SLAW AND A PICKLE

1. White Meat Turkey

18.95

with Crisp Bacon

2. Tuna Salad

16.45

with Sliced Egg

3. Chicken Salad

16.45

with Crisp Bacon

4. Egg Salad

16.45

with Crisp Bacon

5. Boiled Ham and Swiss Cheese

15.95

6. Roast Beef

17.45

with Crisp Bacon

7. *Hamburger

17.45

with Crisp Bacon

8. *Bison Burger

18.95

with Crisp Bacon

9. B.L.T. Club, The Classic

15.45

10. Fried Chicken Cutlet

17.45

with Crisp Bacon

11. Veggie Burger Club

16.45

with Lettuce and Tomato

12. Vegetarian Fried Eggplant Club

16.95

PIZZA SPECIALS

INDIVIDUAL PITA PIZZAS

Vegetarian Greek Pizza

15.45
Spinach and Feta Cheese with Tomato Sauce
topped with Melted Mozzarella Cheese

with Eggplant

16.45

Vegetarian Pizza

15.45
Broccoli, Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Pepper,
Onions & Tomato Sauce, topped
with Melted Mozzarella Cheese

with Sausage

16.45

Cheese Pizza

11.45
Tomato Sauce and Melted Mozzarella Cheese

Crispy Chicken & Cheese Pizza

15.45

Mediterranean Pizza

16.45
Fried Eggplant, Tomato, Red Onion and Feta Cheese

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

16.45
with Bleu Cheese and Melted Mozzarella Cheese
*These menu items are cooked to your request. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk to food-bourne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Before placing your order, please inform your server in a person in your party has a food allergy

SANDWICHES

SERVED WITH PICKLE AND COLE SLAW

Sandwich can be served without bread, on a bed of 
lettuce with tomatoes, cucumbers and garnish + 1.50 extra

SALAD SANDWICHES

Tuna Salad

13.45

with Lettuce & Tomato

Chicken Salad

13.45

with Lettuce & Tomato

Egg Salad

11.45

with Lettuce

with Bacon

12.45

CHEESE SANDWICHES

B.L.T.: Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato

11.45

American Cheese with Lettuce

9.25

Grilled American Cheese

9.25

with Bacon, Ham or Turkey

11.25

Grilled Mozzarella, Cheddar, Pepper Jack or Swiss Cheese

9.45

with Bacon, Ham or Turkey

11.25

Deluxe Your Sandwich

Choice of French Fries or Potato Salad
or Vegetable of the Day
Served with Lettuce and Tomato

CARVING BOARD

SERVED WITH PICKLE AND COLE SLAW

Pastrami or Corned Beef

15.25

Roast Sirloin or Beef

15.25

Virginia Ham

14.25

Roast Turkey, All White Meat

16.25

Served with Tomatoes

+ 1.00 extra

Bagel, Roll, English Muffin, Pita Bread, or 12 Grain Bread

+ 1.45 extra

Gluten Free Bread

+ 1.95 extra

Specialty Sandwiches

SERVED WITH PICKLE AND COLE SLAW

Tuna Melt

16.45
on a Toasted English Muffin with Melted American Cheese,
served with French Fries & Onion Rings

Monte Cristo

17.95

White Meat Turkey on French Toast with Ham and
Melted Swiss Cheese, served with French Fries

*Philly Cheese Steak

17.95
Roast Beef on a Garlic Roll with Fried Onions,
Peppers and Melted Mozzarella Cheese, served with French Fries

*French Dip

17.95
Roast Beef with Melted Mozzarella Cheese
and Au Jus on a Garlic Roll with French Fries

Pastrami Reuben, Corned Beef Reuben or Turkey Reuben

17.95
topped with Sauerkraut & Melted Swiss Cheese on Grilled Rye Bread,
served with French Fries

Fried Filet of Sole

18.95
on a Bun with Lettuce, Tomato and Tarter Sauce served with French Fries

Grilled American Cheese B.L.T.

16.95
Melted American Cheese, Bacon,
Lettuce & Tomato on Grilled 12 Grain Toast, served with French Fries.

*Roumanian Steak Sandwich

28.95
Served on a Roll with Lettuce Tomato, French Fries and Onion Rings

Two All Beef Frankfurters

16.95
on Toasted Buns, served with Sauerkraut, French Fries & Onion Rings

Vegetarian Eggplant Parmigiana

17.95
on a Roll with a touch of Marinara Sauce, topped with Melted Mozzarella Cheese, served with French Fries

Vegetarian Eggplant Surprise

17.95
Seasoned Eggplant in a Light Breading,
Fried & topped with Sauteed Fresh Spinach, Onions, Tomatoes & Mushrooms
with Feta Cheese on a Roll, Served with French Fries

Roasted Turkey Pressed Pita

18.95
Fresh Roasted Turkey,
Swiss Cheese & Spinach in a Pressed Pita, served with French Fries

The Sicilian

17.95
Grilled Chicken, Roasted Red Peppers & Mozzarella Cheese
in a Pressed Pita, served with French Fries

Tuscan Chicken Pressed Pita

17.95
Grilled Chicken, Tomato &
Pepper Jack Cheese in a Pressed Pita, served with French Fries

Vegetarian Eggplant Pressed Pita

17.95
Breaded & Grilled Eggplant,
Sauteed Spinach & Roasted Red Peppers with Melted Mozzarella Cheese in a
Pressed Pita, served with French Fries

Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana

17.95
on a Roll with a touch of Marinara Sauce,
topped with Melted Mozzarella Cheese, served with French Fries

The Melville

17.95

Fried Chicken, Bacon, American Cheese, Lettuce and
Tomato on Toasted Bun, served with French Fries

Old Town Chicken Sandwich

17.95
Fried Chicken, Pepper Jack Cheese,
Avocado, Lettuce & Tomato on Toasted Bun, served with French Fries

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

17.95
Fried Chicken in a Buffalo Sauce,
American Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato on Toasted Bun, with French Fries

Brooklyn Chicken Sandwich

18.95
Grilled Chicken, Fresh Spinach,
Roasted Red Peppers, Mozzarella Cheese on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

Avocado Chicken Sandwich

18.95
Grilled Chicken, Avocado, Swiss Cheese,
Lettuce & Tomato on a Toasted Bun, served with French Fries
*These menu items are cooked to your request. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk to food-bourne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Before placing your order, please inform your server in a person in your party has a food allergy

*Burgers and Buns

MAKE 'EM ANY WAY YOU LIKE 'EM!

Jumbo 1/2 LB. Black Angus Burgers

Served with Cole Slaw and a Pickle

Deluxe Platters

Served with French Fries, Onion Rings, Lettuce, Tomato, Cole Slaw and a Pickle

*Hamburger

12.75

Deluxe Platter

15.25

*Cheeseburger

13.25

Deluxe Platter

15.75

*Pizza Burger

13.75

Deluxe Platter

16.25

*Twin Burgers

20.95

served on One or Two Buns

*Twin Cheeseburgers

21.95

served on One or Two Buns

Turkey Burger

13.25

Deluxe Platter

15.75

Veggie Burger

13.25

Deluxe Platter

15.75

Grilled Breast of Chicken

14.25

Deluxe Platter

16.75

Bacon on Burger

+ 1.95 extra

Mushrooms

+ 0.75 extra

Fried Onions

+ 0.75 extra

Lettuce and Tomato

+ 1.00 extra

Pepper Jack, Mozzarella, Swiss or Cheddar Cheese

+ 1.00 extra

QUESADILLA

Blackened Chicken Quesadilla

20.95
Stuffed with Julienne Fried Onions and Cheese,
garnished with Diced Tomatoes, Julienne
Lettuce, Sour Cream and Salsa

Chicken and Spinach Quesadilla

20.95
Stuffed with Fresh Spinach, Chicken, and
Cheeses, garnished with Diced Tomato,
Julienne Lettuce, Salsa & Sour Cream

Vegetarian Quesadilla

20.45
Stuffed with Fresh Grilled Spinach, Mushrooms,
Broccoli, Peppers, Onions and Cheeses garnished
with Diced Tomato, Julienne Lettuce,
Salsa & Sour Cream.

*Steak Quesadilla

28.95
Stuffed with Onions, Peppers, Filet Mignon Steak,
and Cheeses garnished with Diced Tomato, Julienne
Lettuce, Salsa and Sour Cream

Fresh Turkey & Avocado Quesadilla

21.95
Grilled Turkey, Sliced Avocado and Cheeses
garnished with Diced Tomato, Julienne
Lettuce, Salsa and Sour Cream

Cheese Quesadilla

16.95
Stuffed with an assortment of Cheeses and
garnished with Diced Tomatoes, Julienne
Lettuce, Sour Cream and Salsa

Setauket Specialty Burgers

SERVED WITH PICKLE AND COLE SLAW

*Dallas Burger

18.95

Cheddar Cheese, Avocado, Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato
on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

*Mushroom Swiss Burger

16.75

Mushrooms, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato on a
Toasted Bun served with French Fries

*New York Burger

18.95
Gorgonzola Cheese, Red Onion, Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato
on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

*Cheddar-Bacon Burger

17.95
Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato on a
Toasted Bun served with French Fries

*Grecian Burger

17.95
Feta Cheese, Red Onion and Spinach on a
Toasted Bun served with French Fries

*Fire Pit Bacon Burger

17.95
Pepper Jack Cheese, Bacon, Jalapeños, Lettuce & Tomato
on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

*Gorgonzola Burger

17.95
Julienne Fried Onions, Gorgonzola Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato
on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

*Pepper Jack Burger

17.95
Julienne Fried Onions, Mushrooms, Pepper Jack Cheese,
Lettuce & Tomato on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

Miami Turkey Burger

18.95

Fresh Spinach, Sliced Avocado, Swiss Cheese on a
Toasted Bun served with French Fries

California Turkey Burger

17.95

Mozzarella Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers, Lettuce & Tomato
on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

Seattle Turkey Burger

17.95
Gorgonzola Cheese, Spinach, Red Onion
on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

San Francisco Turkey Burger

18.95
Bacon, Avocado, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce & Tomato
on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries

Vegetarian Veggie Burger

18.95
Pepper Jack Cheese, Sliced Avocado, Lettuce & Tomato
on a Toasted Bun served with French Fries
*These menu items are cooked to your request. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk to food-bourne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Before placing your order, please inform your server in a person in your party has a food allergy

Soups

Our Homemade Soup of the Day

cup - 7.95

Title

bowl - 9.95

French Onion Soup

9.95

Greek Lemon Chicken

10.95

(Avgolemono)

Soups To-Go

Soup of the Day

pint - 9.95

Title

quart - 12.95

French Onion

pint - 9.95

Title

quart - 12.95

Greek Lemon Chicken

pint - 10.95

Title

quart - 13.95

Specialty Salads

ALL SALADS SERVED WITH CHOICE OF DRESSING ON THE SIDE

Greek Salad

$9.95
Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumbers, Onions, Olives,
Grape Leaves and Crumbled Feta Cheese

Title

small - 12.95

Title

medium - 14.95

Title

large - 15.95

Chef Salad

21.95
Sliced Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham, American and Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes,
Avocado Cucumbers, Sliced Egg and Garnish

Greek Spinach Salad

18.45

Fresh Spinach with Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Onions, Olives,
Feta Cheese, Anchovies and Grape Leaves

Caesar Salad

15.95
A Traditional Caesar Salad with Romaine Lettuce, Crunchy Croutons,
Parmigiana Cheese and our Creamy Caesar Dressing

Spinach Salad

18.95
Fresh Spinach with Crispy Bacon, Sliced Mushrooms, Sliced Egg & Croutons

Crispy Chicken Salad

19.95
Crispy Fried Strips of Chicken Breast, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers,
Onions, Roasted Red Peppers, Sliced Egg and Avocado

Traditional Greek Salad

19.95
Wedged Tomato Pieces, Cucumbers, Onions, Olives,
Green Peppers, and Cubed Feta Cheese

Tossed Garden Salad

14.95
Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumbers, Red Onions, Olives, Croutons, Sliced Egg, and Avocado

Salad Topping Add Ons:

$9.95

Grilled Chicken, Gyro, Chicken Gyro, Crispy Chicken

+ 8.95

Sliced Fresh Turkey, Tuna or Chicken Salad

+ 8.95

Fresh Grilled Salmon, Tilapia or Filet of Flounder

+ 10.95

Jumbo Shrimp or *Sliced Steak

+ 12.95

*St. James Steak Salad

34.95
Roumanian Steak, Asparagus, Fresh Mushrooms and Red Onion over Mixed
Greens topped with Gorgonzola Cheese and Lite Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing

Cobb Salad

21.95
Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Bacon, Avocado, Lettuce & Fresh Vegetables

Setauket Spring Salad

22.95
Grilled Chicken Oreganato, Fresh Sliced Avocado, Asparagus, Toasted Almonds
and Shredded Mozzarella Cheese, served over Baby Mesclun Greens, with a
Lite Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing

Stony Brook Spinach Salad

18.95
Fresh Spinach Salad with Cranberry Raisins, Toasted Almonds,
Fresh Mushrooms, Cucumber, Tomato, and Avocado

Strong's Neck Salad

21.95
Baby Mesclun Greens, Toasted Almonds, Fresh Asparagus,
Cranberry Raisins, Croutons, Fresh Turkey, and Avocado

Strawberry and Citrus Salad Delight

20.95
Fresh Strawberries, Oranges, Grapefruit, Toasted Almonds,
Cranberry Raisins served over Mesclun Greens

Poquott Cajun Salad

24.95
Char-Broiled Cajun Salmon, Fresh Mushrooms, Toasted Almonds and
Cranberry Raisins Over Mixed Greens, topped with Gorgonzola Cheese

Buffalo Chicken Bleu Cheese Salad

21.95
Crispy Bacon, Tomato, Red Onions, Peppers and Romaine Lettuce,
served with Bleu Cheese Dressing

Mixed Greens & Goat Cheese Salad

19.95
Fresh Mixed Greens, Toasted Almonds, Fresh Berries (In Season),
Red Onion & Tomato, topped with Crumbled Goat Cheese

Add a Salad

Dinner Sized Greek,
Tossed or Caesar Salad
Added to any Lunch Entree

Salad Platters

SERVED WITH SLICED EGG, LETTUCE, TOMATO, COLE SLAW, CUCUMBER AND GARNISH

Sliced Hard Boiled Eggs

15.95

Tuna Salad

17.45

Chicken Salad

17.45

Egg Salad

16.45

Salad Platter Trio

21.45
Egg Salad, Tuna Salad and Chicken Salad
*These menu items are cooked to your request. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk to food-bourne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. Before placing your order, please inform your server in a person in your party has a food allergy

North Shore Wraps

SERVED WITH FRENCH FRIES

Greek Salad Wrap

17.95

with Grilled Chicken Breast

Caesar Salad Wrap

17.95
with Grilled Chicken Breast

Pastrami or Corned Beef Reuben Wrap

17.95
with Melted Swiss and Sauerkraut

Gyro or Chicken Gyro Wrap

16.95
with Lettuce, Tomato and Onions

Chicken Salad Wrap

17.95
with Lettuce and Tomato

Tuna Salad Wrap

16.95
with Lettuce and Tomato

Roast Beef Wrap

17.45
with Lettuce and Tomato

Fresh Turkey Wrap

17.45
with Lettuce and Tomato

Veggie Burger Wrap

17.45

with Lettuce and Tomato

Vegetarian Wrap

17.95
Sauteed Fresh Spinach with Mushrooms, Tomatoes, Broccoli, Onions and Feta Cheese

Crispy Chicken Breast Caesar Salad Wrap

17.95

Crispy Chicken Breast Greek Salad Wrap

17.85

*Steak Wrap

26.95
Filet Mignon Steak, Gorgonzola Cheese, Red Onion,
Tomato & Mixed Greens in a Whole Wheat Wrap

Turkey Club Wrap

19.95
Roasted Turkey, Bacon and Swiss Cheese, with Lettuce
& Tomato in a Whole Wheat Wrap

Buffalo Bleu Cheese Wrap

17.95
Fried Buffalo Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Tomato and
Red Onion in a Whole Wheat Wrap

Fiesta Wrap

17.95
Grilled Chicken, Black Beans, Pepper Jack Cheese, Red Onion &
Romaine Lettuce in a Whole Wheat Wrap

Spring Wrap

17.95
Fresh Spinach, Mushrooms, Asparagus, Toasted Almonds,
Cranberry Raisins & Gorgonzola Cheese in a Whole Wheat Wrap

Southern Turkey Wrap

18.95
Roasted Turkey, Pepper Jack Cheese, Black Beans, Rice &
Sliced Avocado in a Whole Wheat Wrap

Appetizers

Appetizer Sampler

18.95
Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Fingers, Potato Skins and Buffalo Wings

Mozzarella Sticks

(6) - 13.75

Loaded Potato Skins

(4) - 14.95
Bacon and Cheese or Broccoli and Cheddar

Chicken Fingers

14.95
Strips of Fried Chicken Breast with Honey Mustard or BBQ Sauce

Boneless Buffalo Chicken Wings

16.95
served with Celery and Bleu Cheese Dressing

Loaded Cheese Fries

11.95
with Bacon and Mozzarella Cheese

French Fries

7.45

with Melted American Cheese

8.45

with Melted Mozzarella or Swiss

8.95

Sweet Potato French Fries

8.95

Buffalo Wings

17.95

Buffalo Style Hot Wings

15.95

served with Celery and Bleu Cheese Dressing

Jumbo Shrimp Scampi

(6) - 19.95

Fresh Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail

(6) - 19.95

Brooke Walsh -

I always love going to the Setauket diner, it’s always a positive experience!! (: The waitresses and waiters are extremely friendly, food is always amazing, every time I step foot into the diner.. Gus always greets us with smile and my boyfriend and I enjoy our conversations with him! We love Gus and everyone at the Setauket diner ☺️

James Yeary -

This has become my go-to diner over the last year or so. All of the food is 10/10 and the owner/servers provide such an awesome experience. Would highly recommend!!

Andrew Negron -

What an amazing vibe. I feel like I in a different world here. This might not be the most important thing to everyone, but the over medium egg sandwich is one of a kind. The bacon? Prefect! The roll? Like it came right out of the oven. And an over medium egg is a hard cook to get perfect. But every time I get one it's on the money. Thank you guy.

Rick E. -

Cozy and comfortable local restaurant with great food and a wonderful host. You always feel welcomed here.

DOWNLOAD OUR MENU

CALL US

HOURS

MONDAY - SATURDAY
7:00 AM - 9:00 PM

SUNDAYS
7:00 AM - 8:00 PM

CONNECT